My response to Rusty Spears on Rip off report

Wed, 01/23/2013 - 6:05pm

 On rip off report, I've seen a complaint against Milton Kapner ["Brother Nathanael"] and his hate speech. A guy under the name of Rusty Spears defends Milton Kapner and claims, against the mounting pile of evidence to the contrary, that Milton Kapner is not against Jews and just against Zionists, I respond  here because the blockquotes did not appear as such and I was not happy at how the style of writing came out. My comment is right below:

   First off, I've seen Milton Kapner's videos. He is indeed anti-Semitic and hateful. All his videos are about the Jews wanting to control this or that. On his website, he holds Jews responsible for the Armenian genocide and claims that Kosher certification on foods is really part of some plan of some beast to attack. Mr Spears claim that:

Milton Kapner is in no wise racist, nor is he anti-semitic.   Each and every assertion of this Report is unfounded and can not be borne out by a cursory examination of the website in question.

Actually, all his videos show what a vile anti-Semite he is. And on his website, he advocates for anti-Semitic discrimination against Jews by saying that they should be barred from holding political office. He praises the Byzantine empire for not allowing Jews to hold political office and calls that form of discrimination a "healthy political system" and claims that it's "the only way that Political Judaism can be stopped".  Nevertheless, Spears lives in his own little cocoon, where no matter how much of a vile anti-Semite that person is, he/she is really just "anti-Zionist", especially if they don't forget to mention Israel during their anti-Semitic rants. Never mind that Zionism is merely the national liberation movement of the Jewish people. So being against Zionism is being against the right of the Jews to establish a country on their own soil, which is anti-Semitic. But leaving that aside, Spears inserts that false distinction into Milton Kapner's mouth even though he never even pretended to make that distinction. For Spears claims:

The writer seems to intentionally be conflating Kapner's criticism and exposure of world Zionist ethnocentrism and political conspiracies as attacks on the Jewish ethnicity.  Indeed, it is due in large part ot Kapner's research and painstaking exposition of actual historical documents  that persons such as this writer have even become aware of the sinister long-term machinations of the Zionist forces.   Kapner has stressed quite explicitly that these forces are inimical even to the interests of the vast majority of those who identify as Jews.

Which Milton Kapner have you been listening to? The one, who says that Jews should not hold political office? Milton Kapner never made this false distinction and even goes after people, who make this false distinction. Take Neturai Karta for example. They kiss up to anti-Semites like Ahmadinejad. Yet, Milton Kapner attacks them for not directly attacking the Jewish religion. He says, "Though I agree with the [Neturai Karta] rabbis that Zionism is bad, I can't agree with them that Judaism is good". As seen from the video on the hyperlink, Milton Kapner [aka "brother Nathanael"] still attacks Neturai Karta for being Jews despite the fact that they even violate Shabbat to support anti-semites everywhere, especially the ones in Iran and the "Palestinian" terrorists, who promote this scam known as Palestinianism. So again, what world do you live in, Rusty? Rusty seems to be an appropriate name for you, since that's how you look at the world, a world, where even Hitler could probably just be "anti-Zionist" and "not anti-Semitic". In addition, Milton Kapner attacks fellow self-hating Jews, who draw the false distinction of anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic, for being Jews as well. And yet the people on StormFront attack Milton Kapner for having been a Jew himself. Rusty Spears says:

The writer's assertion that Kapner is only taken seriously by 'folks who never bothered to study history' is ironic, in that a careful examination of independent research and a concordance of the full body of knowledge and writings on these topics will tend to confirm the veracity of his writings.   It's hard to avoid the impression that the writer of the Report is serving someone else's agenda, or is just reactively spouting talking-points that have been given him by the very forces Kapner struggles to illluminate for us in his writings.

No, the writer of this report is saying the truth. Milton Kapner doesn't have facts, just hate speech and superstition. He has no research and no nothing. Period. End of story. He's an embarrassment to most Orthodox Christians. He only appeals to the anti-Semitic morons on the internet, who worship him and help him to post his venom all over the internet. He appeals to dopes like you, Rusty; but not to sane Orthodox Christians.   Rusty has a problem with the name calling in this report while supporting and defending Milton Kapner's hate speech. Spears writes:

It seems to me that one must be almost unbelievably courageous to call attention to the disingeniousness and deception that is Zionism and its religious corrolary of rabbinical Judaism --- since this is the most taboo topic in the Western world today.  

Well, Jewish nationalism goes its roots from God's covenant with Avraham. But rabbinic Judaism was around centuries before the modern movement of Zionism came about. You see, Spears. You claim that Milton Kapner just hates Zionists and not Jews, despite the countless amount of evidence that shows that he does hate Jews. And then you attack the Jewish religion yourself. Perfect example of anti-Semitic hypocrisy and how their claims don't hold water. This goes to show that you really do support Milton Kapner's anti-Semitism and that you are just as stupidly ignorant as he is. That proves my point that the only supporters he has are dopes on the internet, who have loud voices; but hardly any brain cells. That's why you have the audacity to claim, against the mounting pile of evidence to the contrary, that Milton Kapner "is engaged in a labor of love, not of hate". Again, what planet are you living on? Do you even listen to what he says and read what he writes? Cause anyone, who listens to him or reads a word he types, would know that he's a hate monger. There is no doubt about that. And btw, Milton Kapner is also a liar. He claims that he left Judaism and became a Christian in 1971. But in reality, he was a Jew all the way up to 2002. Back in 2002, a synagogue known as Young Israel of Brookline showed him hospitality and welcomed him. Due to his behavior such as harassing the congregants there, the people there lost tolerance and got rid of him. Back then, he claimed,"I've been excommunicated. It's the worst thing that can happen to a Jew." So if he lies about when he left Judaism, why should we believe anything else he claims about himself? Come on. He's not a priest. There is no evidence of the Greek Orthodox church ordaining him or any of that. He's a phony and a fraud. And he's a liar. Period.